(3 out of 5 stars)Tom Cruise, Meryl Streep, and
Robert Redford are the all-star cast in this Redford directed movie
that audiences probably stayed away from because of its current
events story of a battle occurring in Afghanistan where a senator
wants a new plan of action, a reporter just wants to exploit the
story, and a professor wants nothing to do with the war, but see his
former students come home and teach a current student to be all that
he can be.
Redford
labors in this film as he does with most films he directs, but it
does not hurt the film. Streep and Cruise do not capture the top of
their game acting that they normally do and ‘B’ list actors may have
worked better in these parts. Redford as an actor seemed tired, just
as much as he was tired of his students not achieving what they
could. Was he intending on inspiring these students? What works for
this film has nothing to do with acting or directing though and that
is why I say this is a movie to see.
This movie is
Altman-esque as it contains four stories that all interconnect, but
in a direct way, much less indirect as Altman chooses. This is even
more direct than Babel in its interrelating stories. Overall,
this is simply a political movie much like Primary Colors was
in its day giving an obvious viewpoint of the current events of
politics today. I think this is very interesting.
Cruise is the
senator who tells his “plan” to Streep while the plan is actually
already in progress. He is feeding the media what he wants the
public to hear. Streep is the reporter wanting the story, hoping not
to sell out and tell the senator’s version until her boss tells her
to write it anyway. It is not about telling the public the truth; it
is about selling newspapers. Redford symbolizes the general public
hating war, but at the same time having hope in the generation of
young people who could make a difference. Andrew Garfield plays the
slacker kid who should be doing better and is clueless why an adult
(Redford) would care about him. Michael Pena and Derek Luke play
previous students of Redford’s who although of a minority race have
such honor for the United States of America that they enlist with
the army to uphold the freedom that they cherish that the general
majority takes for granted.
One may think
this movie is stereotyping, but I would like to suggest that this is
a well written movie about what is really going on in America today.
Most people do not want to admit this and will say the film is too
political or is just stereotypical, and if it is. It does not matter
because that is the appropriate way to write this film. People do
not like to hear the truth, which is partly what this film is trying
to get across. The last scene is a wonderful example as the student
watched the news seeing a report of the entertainment world while
the results of the war scroll at the bottom. What do we care about;
what should we care about?
Similar
recommended titles: The Manchurian Candidate, The
Kingdom, Babel
By: Josh Wheeler - Contributing Writer